i HATE tingle lube with a passion but loved the durex thickness so i'm tempted to try a normal version, aquaglide gel is good too, nice a thick but still water based.
The System JO H2O Strawberry Kiss is my favourite for oral. For foreplay, I'm a fan of tingle lube. And by that point, I don't need anything for penetration!
I use silicone sex toys often, so I tend to go through a lot of water-based lube. I've used Liquid Silk, Sliquid, Lovehoney flavoured lubes but my favourite by far is the Lovehoney Discover Anal Lubricant. It's so lovely and thick that it doesn't run straight off the toys, it actually stays in place and doesn't dry too quickly either. It has virtually no smell to it but does have a horrible aftertaste, so of you want lube for oral use then I'd suggest one of the Sliquid Swirl lubes or the Lovehoney Passionfruit one. If you're looking for a good water-based lube that will really lubricate then I'd highly recommend the Discover anal one.