Which of the two plugs would be better?

I finally decided to buy myself a vibrating plug. There are two that I found at a reasonable price and now I've got a dilemma:
No1 is inflatable and has a full scale of vibrations, it's from GJ or Seven Creations, black or fleshy but it's latex
No2 is silicone, beautiful violet, waterproof with a suction cup but has only 4 speeds and doesn't inflate.
No1: http://www.lovehoney.co.uk/product.cfm?p=6406
No2: http://www.lovehoney.co.uk/product.cfm?p=14561
Which one would you buy if you were me? I fantasized about the inflated one for a bit of time but since I've never had a plug in me I don't know if it would really fulfill my expectations. And since I've never touched a silicone toy I don't know how they feel. How soft are they?