For anyone that has done a full renovation of a house, would you do it again?

My wife and I are about to buy a dilapidated farmhouse, and the RICS report reads like horror story. Only 4 things haven’t been given a ‘red’ category - the boiler, the water feed, windows and external doors.

We know this is going to be a huge project, and our friends are 50/50 between thinking it’s an amazing opportunity and that we’re absolutely crazy and will ruin our lives.

I’ll be doing a lot of the work myself (I’m quite handy), but will get specialists in for jobs I can’t do like roofing, solar, heating system etc. It’s going to involve the roof coming off and replaced, chimney rebuilding, all internal walls being rebuilt, upstairs floors being entirely pulled up and replaced, new bathroom and kitchen, downstairs ceilings ripped down, replaced and insulated, downstairs floors excavated and replaced with limecrete with underfloor heating, all walls hacked clean of plaster and replastered with lime plaster, outside render hacking off and repointing. Basically everything apart from the four stone walls…

What are your success and horror stories? Also interested if anyone has fitted a little nod to their kinks in a renovation like swing brackets, toy storage or even a full dungeon?

I have renovated many houses for clients and myself, full rebuilds like you are doing.

Don’t cheep yourself on the basics and I tried with clients to go down the renewables route but now max out your ability to generate and store power and go for the max insulation.

Solar roof and or ground array if you have the land, if you are out in the sticks 2/3 days electricity storage, air source heat pump and insulate wherever you can. Especially if you are hacking the external render off.

If you do all the grunt work you will save a massive amount of money and there are so many YouTube guides nowadays you can fix most things.

Need any detailed advice just @ me and I will do what I can to help.

Avoid gas, lpg or anything like that.

This is what I do for the main part of my living.

I wish you all the best and the friends that help are rockstars.

1 Like

What is the problem with lpg as we were looking at a house that has lpg central heating?

1 Like

Thanks for the reply, that sounds like a fascinating career! We have ASHP, solar and batteries in our current house and will definitely be doing the same there. We’re going to take our existing batteries with us and add some extra capacity too. Solar will also be going up whilst we do the roof.

My aim with it is do it once and do it properly. We’ve got quite extensive outbuildings that eventually we’d like to convert in to holiday lets, but are going to require significant additional capital so that’s a few years down the line, but once we do that I’d like to look at a GSHP vertical array to heat those, as well as maxing out solar on them all.

1 Like

Everything has its own issues @Wood-Nymph It is what option is the one that limits those issues for you and depends on the area you will be living in. But in general

It’s the long term cost buy and use once, can be stolen and drained, leaking into the surrounding soils, availability and supply chain winter months it can get tricky.

1 Like

Sounds like you have your bases covered.

Look at the outside insulation and in addition to the inner wall it takes 4/6” extra but you are putting a new roof on so the overhand of the joists won’t be an issue. Talk to your engineer also things like sheep’s wall and straw bales for internal insulation can be cheeper with higher R values and have high fire resistance values too

1 Like

Our first house we gutted and I did a lot myself but was much, much younger! Last big project was totally gutting the lounge/dining area 7 years ago. Have made everything easier to maintain and decorate and no, at 63 I wouldn’t again! Next project is kitchen/utility and will get professionals in!

I’m of course not calling you old when I say this, but I’m 37 so feel like now is the best time to do a project like this, but wouldn’t want to be much older.

2 Likes

Have you used the insulated lime plaster at all? Currently unsure whether to just lime plaster straight on to the internal walls but use the insulated stuff, or overboard with wood wool first then plaster over that.

It boils down to the cost of doing the whole house as insulating between floors and into the joist cavities are important too.

Do you have architect or local council building inspector as local building regs might have a minimum R value requirement for what is essentially a new build.

In general I’ve seen framing then wall wood wool with a lime plaster and a finishing skim on top.

We have not done a full reno like you are doing, but have done major work on 3 homes. As is usually the case, you have to consider the initial cost to the final value, and not dig a financial hole you cannot recover from by going top shelf on everything, especially if the surrounding neighborhood does not support it. A real estate person I knew once told me, always buy the cheapest house in a neighborhood, then renovate it. Also, consider your time frame. Are you going to live in it long term, or shorter and flip it ? Of the houses we have redone, the current one is the most extensive job, and while it has been rewarding to do it, it has cost more than we anticipated, and may be difficult to recoup our total investment if we sold anytime in the near future due to the depressed market compared to when we bought it. The market will recover, and event we will be fine. It has been rewarding in a lot of ways to do the work, and see the transition from an ugly duckling to a wonderful place to live. Would we do it again ? Maybe not at our ages, mid 70’s, but certainly if we were 10 -15 years younger.