First off, apologies for the delay in announcing the winner of October's prize. We took Bath-Bi-Guy's suggestion, threw the reviews mentioned on this thread into a hat and plucked out the winner -- they're featured on the home page now...
I'll start a new thread for the November winner. Please nominate away and we'll do the same again.
Hope you all think that's fair - a short-list combined with a little bit of luck...!