Hello bi 220
As you can see everyone has a different preference when it comes to toys but I personally think that when you are starting out with exploring anal play it is important to not go large straightaway and use lube and i can see from what you have ordered that is exactly what you have done.
I have anal beads, vibrating butt plug, glass dildo, glass butt plug, dildo and what I use really really just depends on my mood. Sex is all about exploring and having fun along the way so enjoy your purchases.